Whats better? TNA or WWE?

[Lizzy]

Okay, guys and girls (if there are some )...

 

Which show do you like?

 

Both?

Just WWE? (Why)

Just TNA? (Why)

[Gabberbone]

I like both.

WWE is great for the storylines, the show and the number of wrestlers but some doesn't have anything special and always use the same skills that are boring.

 

TNA is better than WWE for the action and the wrestling quality, they do spectacular skills and are always innovatives but the storylines are not as good as WWE.

[Rudolf]

I don't like both I like only independed zone, puroresu and MMA or K1

[Euz]

Both sucks cuz WWE and TNA aren't pro wrestling, The Top quality of matches is in indies and Japan. And that's the bottom line

[johniss]

...but WWE is on the spotlight thanks to their entertainment. Do independents/indies give fans comparable angles or storylines? I don't think so. Well, McMahons federation is my pick now. Hope, Ring of Honor is going to weekly, that supposedly rises this fed on the TNA level, at least. Edytowane 20 Marca 2009 przez johniss

[Mankind89]

I like only WWE not beacause of their wrestling but i love {i mean was loving it at Attitide era and before of it} their entertainment. TNA for me is nothing less than another NWA local promotion. Like Paul E. says TNA did not got a trademark {i dont mean that stupid slogan "we cross the line" i mean distinctive character something that you can find only in TNA.} is not a competitor to WWE. They have to do something to break up from the NWA [like Eastern Championship Wrestling did , i mean Shane Douglas throw the NWA title away and start a new Era like he said "the era of sport of proffesional wrestling ."} Now they aren't persuading me. I'm not saying i'm just saying.

[nekrophage]

imo it's WWE 'couse i like entertainment what this fed presents. Last times TNA sucks (see Destination X).

[LooseCannon]

Both sucks cuz WWE and TNA aren't pro wrestling, The Top quality of matches is in indies and Japan. And that's the bottom line

 

Ok, I agree with this "Top Quality Matches" when it comes to ROH and Japan. Sometimes PWG and Chikara, but that's all. There are houndreds of independent promotions and usually matches are pretty crappy. The number of good wrestlers is not limitless. So, if some indy fed is able to sign wrestlers like Hero or Danielson, it has an advantage in great and memorable matches. So it's some kind of ignorance, saying "WWE and TNA suck, Indies Rulz" because it's not indies overall, but a couple of promotions which have good matches.

 

I think this diversity in wrestling promotions is very good and I don't see it in a way most indy fans with the attitude like: "My toy is better than yours". WWE and ROH are totally different, have different audience, different kind of product. There's no sense in comparing them. But when it comes to, lets say, CZW and IWA-MS, they're both very risky promotions with lots of violence, blood and wild brawls. So you can easily compare them because they fight for the same audience and are similar in style. This indy fans hatred to WWE is ridiculous.

 

And what each promotion stands for:

WWE - family friendly soup opera with heroes and villains

TNA - nursing home for former WCW and WWE stars with a some good wrestlers and the best women's division

ROH - technical wrestling

NOAH&AJPW - technique + aspiration for making pro wrestling as much realistic as it's possible

CHIKARA - high fly mostly (I haven't watched it for a long time so maybe it changed now)

Dragon Gate - high fly

PWG - technique

IWA-MS - violence, brawl

CZW - same as above

AAA, CMLL - Lucha + entertainment

[Euz]

I ain't watchnig hundreds of U.S indies to say the whole independent rules or suckz, and I ain't say that I meant quite of US Indies. For reason, In Mexico (Lucha Azteca) and Puerto Rico (IWA), quality of matches is bigger then "U.S. Well Known indies" like PWG, FIP etc. In Japan is very hardly to find promotion without good quality of wrestling. Even though, If you'd say garbage hardcore, I say Apache Pro , If you'd say shity lucharesu, I say Osaka Pro That's my opinion.

 

For last year i've got a lot of hate for U.S. main stream. That makes my eye open for wrestling of the rest of the world.

[kmL]

I like WWE and TNA too 'cause sometimes i wanna see six sides ring. That's very cool i think But more than that i love Lucha Libre <3

[ukaszoczko]

I like WWE because WWE has good wrestlers but I like TNA as well because somtimes I want to see somethink else than WWE I mean somthink else like the cross match and the 8 or six sides ring

[blackie619]

TNA has great talent but Vince Russo and Dutch Mantell keep screwing them...They have some good months (The Build-up to Lockdown was great) but they keep making the same mistakes that bring down WCW.

 

WWE...Christ...After I saw yesterday what they did to the Ron Killings gimmick...Damn...

[Koper137]

Hmmm. I like and WWE and TNA. TNA Have a more young, talents. AJ Styles or too Chris Sabin. In the Future TNA will be a more better than WWE but at the this moment, WWE is better for me. Vote for WWE .

[Szocia]

It's hard to say, in WWE i like superstars and storylines but TNA have more action but

i don't like those strange superstars like abbyss or sting.

So i will say WWE.

[Stefan-2006]

i hate sports entertaiment so i hate both promotion! because i want to see "real"wrestling! i love the hardcore style like CZW,IWA-MS,IWA-EC,WXW,XPW,old ECW and BJW did it!